State of the art

Methodology:

  • Searching for and selecting publications on French and international multidisciplinary article search portals using keywords.
  • Classification of the bibliography according to the types of work (public reports, research reports, articles)
  • Grouping of publications based on three perspectives:

Historical perspective on healthcare education
Objective: to gain a better understanding of how the training of healthcare professionals has always been shaped by technological and pedagogical innovations.

Digital technology in healthcare
Objective: to identify the key issues relating to the development of digital tools in the healthcare sector.

Digital tools for and within training programmes
Objective: to identify the challenges facing training programmes with the development of digital tools; to catalogue current research and projects; and to highlight emerging questions concerning digital training in healthcare.

Interim review of the state of the art

The initial findings of this review of the current state of the art are particularly useful for understanding the difficulties and challenges associated with the roll-out of new digital training programmes in the healthcare sector. It is indeed striking to note that our CAPS’UL project is facing issues that are very similar to those highlighted by research to date.

Our project aims to support training professionals in integrating the competence frameworks produced by public policy. However, between the production of this framework and its implementation on the ground, there is a process which, at every stage, requires multiple interpretations and adaptations in line with the variety and diversity of local contexts.

This constant interplay between established frameworks and published guidelines on the one hand; and a nuanced reception of these frameworks, high expectations, but a clear lack of human, material and financial resources to implement them on the other, means that our team must systematically proceed in stages. These stages take place both top-down—involving translation, co-construction and production—and bottom-up—involving evaluation, revision, monitoring and reporting on results.

However, all these stages come up against the realities on the ground. What the current state of the art enables us to understand is that the adoption of new pedagogical practices, new knowledge and new approaches in education can only take place over periods of varying lengths, during which those working on the ground do not absorb them fully and immediately, but select and draw upon them as they go along.

It therefore seems necessary for a project such as ours to incorporate this process-oriented dimension by producing and disseminating hybrid tools which, by their very design, allow practitioners on the ground to choose and select the elements they deem relevant, whilst offering them a range of resources they can use according to the situation and audience.

The current state of the art also indicates that assessing changes in skills before and after digital health training, such as that we are delivering in our project, is enhanced if it is not based solely on the assessment of students, but is combined with a self-assessment by the students themselves, enabling an evaluation of digital literacy in general terms.

[Translate to English:]